Fiduciary Compliance in 2026: A Practical Blueprint for HR Leaders

Employee benefits are under a microscope like never before. What was once considered a routine HR function is now an area of legal, financial, and reputational risk for employers. A growing wave of fiduciary lawsuits is now targeting health and welfare benefits, pharmacy pricing, and voluntary benefits.

For HR leaders and decision makers, the message is clear: Fiduciary compliance is no longer something that can be presumed in the background — It is now a critical business imperative. In this guide, we break down what’s driving this shift and provide a clear, practical framework for building strong fiduciary compliance for welfare benefit plans.

The Rise of Fiduciary Risk in Employee Benefits

How Did We Get Here?
Fiduciary responsibilities under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) have existed since the inception of ERISA in 1974. However, for decades, most plans operated with limited scrutiny. That changed dramatically for retirement plans over the past 10 – 15 years as a surge in 401(k) fiduciary lawsuits exposed issues such as:

• Excessive administrative fees
• Poor investment selection
• Conflicts of interest
• Lack of fee transparency

Now, the same scrutiny is expanding into health and welfare plans. Employers are being challenged with ensuring that plan decisions are prudent, fees are reasonable and transparent, vendors are properly monitored, and fiduciary processes are well documented to demonstrate compliance with ERISA requirements. 

The New Wave: Health Plan Fiduciary Lawsuits
Recent litigation is rapidly reshaping the employee benefits landscape.

In 2024, Johnson & Johnson faced a lawsuit alleging that the company overpaid for prescription drugs because of inadequate oversight of its pharmacy benefit manager (PBM). A widely cited example from this lawsuit indicated the health plan paid more than $10,000 for a prescription drug that was available for less than $100 without insurance.

Similar lawsuits followed against other organizations, including Wells Fargo, JP Morgan, and Northwestern University. This continuing stream of lawsuits signals a broader trend of increased fiduciary scrutiny. More recently, litigation has expanded beyond health plans to include voluntary benefits, with a specific focus on low loss ratios and high broker compensation.

The key takeaway is clear. Fiduciary challenges are no longer focused solely on retirement plans. They are now shining a spotlight on every corner of the employee benefits ecosystem. 

Why Fiduciary Compliance Matters

Lawsuits Defining the Future Landscape
Even though some early cases were dismissed for lack of standing, the trend is unmistakable:

• Lawsuits are becoming more sophisticated
• Legal theories are evolving
• Courts are increasingly willing to let cases proceed

In this environment, strong governance processes, well documented decision-making, and fastidious oversight are necessary for an effective fiduciary risk management strategy. For HR leaders, this requires a shift away from a reactive approach toward a more proactive and disciplined compliance framework.
 

The Challenge: Complexity Without Clear Rules
One of the biggest frustrations for employers is that ERISA does not provide a simple compliance checklist. Instead, it requires:

• Consideration of all relevant facts and circumstances
• Ongoing prudent decision-making
• Continuous monitoring and documentation

When these expectations are combined with dozens of regulatory requirements, multiple vendor relationships, and increasingly complex plan designs, it becomes easy to understand why many organizations feel overwhelmed by the growing scope of fiduciary responsibility.  

Key Takeaways for HR Leaders

To build a defensible and effective fiduciary compliance strategy:

• Understand ERISA fiduciary obligations
• Adopt a structured framework
• Prioritize documentation
• Regularly review vendor contracts and fees
• Establish a fiduciary committee with clear accountability
• Simplify your approach to ensure sustainability over time  

Are You Prepared for the Next Wave of Fiduciary Scrutiny?

Fiduciary oversight is evolving quickly and the stakes are high. Now is the time to review your fiduciary processes and ensure you have a well-defined governance framework in place.

If you’re unsure where to begin, our team is here to help. Vita has developed a Fiduciary Compliance program that is at once comprehensive and simple for our clients. There are 172 documented elements to the program . . . and Vita drives 90% of them. Some components are small, some are large, but all are crucial to comprehensive compliance. Contact us to start a conversation about building a practical fiduciary compliance blueprint for your organization.

Talk to a Compliance Advisor →